You know the struggle: you want the long lashes of your dreams without the smudging nightmare that often comes with it. Enter tubing mascaras, the unsung heroes of the lash world. But which one should you bet your bucks on — Too Faced or Tarte?
| Feature | Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara | Tarte Tubing Mascara |
|---|---|---|
| Waterproof | ✓ | ✗ |
| Volume Boosting | ✓ | ✗ |
| Lengthening | ✓ | ✓ |
| Smudge-Proof | ✗ | ✓ |
| Price | $27 | $24 |
| Vegan Formula | ✗ | ✓ |
✅ too faced Pros
- Provides a dramatic volume boost.
- Waterproof formula ideal for long days.
- Lengthens lashes significantly.
❌ too faced Cons
- Can smudge under high humidity.
- Pricier than some competitors.
- Not a vegan formula.
✅ tarte tubing mascara Pros
- Excellent at lengthening without clumping.
- Smudge-proof even in humid conditions.
- Vegan and cruelty-free formula.
❌ tarte tubing mascara Cons
- Doesn’t offer much volume.
- Not waterproof.
- Can be a little challenging to remove.
Performance: Volume vs. Length
Too Faced reigns supreme if you’re chasing after big, bold lashes. The volume you get is akin to wearing falsies, minus the hassle of glue. However, it has a tendency to smudge if you’re sweating it out at the gym or caught in a downpour, despite its waterproof claim. Tarte, on the other hand, excels in the lengthening department. It creates a clean, naturally extended look — perfect for everyday wear. It won’t give you the drama of Too Faced, but it certainly won’t leave you with raccoon eyes either.
Build Quality: Brush Design and Formula
Too Faced uses an hourglass-shaped brush that grabs onto lashes to coat them in a thick formula, building major volume with just a couple of swipes. But this can also mean clumping if you’re not careful. Tarte’s brush is more like a traditional comb, which helps in separating lashes and reducing clumps, making it more user-friendly for newbies. Its tubing formula is unique as it forms tiny tubes around each lash, ensuring a smudge-free experience.
Value: Cost vs. Benefits
You’re looking at a $3 difference, which might not seem like much, but it adds up over time. With Too Faced, you’re paying for the bold volume and a waterproof feature, albeit with some smudging risks. Tarte is slightly cheaper and offers a vegan formula and smudge-proof wear but at the cost of volume. It’s about what you prioritize: drama with some risk, or reliability with a natural finish.
Both mascaras have their quirks. Too Faced can clump if you’re not careful, requiring a skilled hand or a lash comb. Tarte might be smudge-proof, but it can be a pain to remove without a good cleanser, leaving you tugging at your lashes more than you’d like.
Our Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
If you’re all about that drama and don’t mind a little touch-up here and there, Too Faced is your go-to. It’s perfect for evenings out or when you’re feeling extra. Tarte is for you if you want a fuss-free, natural look that holds up through your 9-to-5 grind without a single smudge. It’s a safe bet for those with sensitive eyes or who value vegan beauty.
Is Too Faced mascara suitable for sensitive eyes?
It’s not specifically formulated for sensitive eyes. If you have concerns, Tarte might be a better choice as it’s vegan and tends to be gentler.
How do you remove Tarte tubing mascara?
Use warm water and gentle pressure. The tubes slide off easily with a bit of patience, but a good cleanser can help speed up the process.
Does either mascara flake throughout the day?
Too Faced can occasionally flake if applied too thick, especially in dry conditions. Tarte typically holds up better against flaking due to the tubing technology.